Claims

Please Call your local Neighbors Insurance office to start the claims process. If your trying to start a claim during non-business hours you may contact your provider below to begin the claims process.

 

Broome County Coop 1-866-921-BCIC(2242)

Dryden Mutual (800) 782-0154 or (800) 556-5802

Erie and Niagara Insurance claims@enia.com or 1-800-234-9876

Foremost Insurance 1-800-527-3907.

GMAC 1-800-468-3466

Main Street America/National Grange Mutual 1-877-425-2467

Merchants (877) 533-6330

Mercury Insurance 1-800-987-6000

Midstate Mutual 1-800-826-8520

NY CENTRAL Mutual 1-888-234-6926

Peerless Insurance 1-800-522-7152 for our 24-hour ANYTIME

Preferred Mutual 1-800-333-7642

Progressive Insurance 1-800-274-4499

Roadside Assistance 1-888-776-2778

Selective Flood 877-348-0552

Sterling Insurance 800-462-4661

Travelers Insurance 1-800-252-4633 or 1.800.CLAIM33

Utica National Insurance Company (800) 274-1914

 

The Following companies, you have to call the agency to report a claim

Ontario Insurance